British Deaf Association
  • ABOUT US
      • BDA Manifesto
      • What we stand for
      • Our Work
      • Board
      • Strategic Vision
      • Management Team
      • What the BDA means to you
      • History
      • Annual Reviews
  • WHAT WE DO
    • SIGN LANGUAGE
      • BSL in GCSE
      • BSL Act Now! Campaign
      • Legal Status for BSL
      • Our work in Government
      • BSL Facts & Resources
      • Research & Consultations
      • Sign Language Week
      • National BSL Day
    • OUR PROJECTS
      • Community Development
      • Training & Consultancy
      • Deaf Roots & Pride
      • Family Sign in the Home
      • Signs of our times
      • Advocacy Service
      • Heritage
      • Dementia Toolkit
      • Dementia Research
      • England Loneliness Project
    • VIDEO INFORMATION IN BSL
      • COVID-19
      • Family Sign at Home
      • Health & Wellbeing
      • Hate Crime Prevention (Scotland)
      • Derbyshire Crime Project
      • Leicestershire Deaf Forum COVID-19 Project
      • Personal Independence Payment (PIP)
      • Access to Justice
  • NEWS & EVENTS
    • NEWS
      • All News
      • England
      • Northern Ireland
      • Scotland
      • Wales
    • EVENTS
      • BSL Conference 2025
      • National BSL Day
      • All Events
      • England
      • Northern Ireland
      • Scotland
      • Wales
    • OTHER
      • British Deaf News
      • World Federation of the Deaf
      • European Union of the Deaf
      • SHARE: The Deaf Visual Archive
      • Sign Language Week
      • Deaf Awareness Week
  • GET INVOLVED
    • SUPPORT US
      • Make a difference
      • Ways to Donate
      • Fundraise for the BDA
      • Fundraising Opportunities
      • Sending Sponsorship Money
      • In-Memoriam Donations
      • Gifts in Wills
      • Our Supporters
    • JOIN US
      • Current Job Opportunities
      • Become a Member
    • MORE FROM US
      • Newsletter
  • CONTACT
    • GET IN TOUCH
      • Contact Form
    • OUR OFFICES
      • England – London
      • England – Derby
      • Northern Ireland – Belfast
      • Scotland – Glasgow
      • Wales – Cardiff
    • SOCIAL MEDIA
      • Twitter
      • Facebook
      • Facebook – British Deaf News
      • Instagram
      • Linkedin
      • YouTube
  • SHOP
  • |
  • MEMBERSHIP
  •  |
  • DONATE
  • ABOUT US
    • ABOUT US
      • BDA Manifesto
      • What we stand for
      • Our Work
      • Board
      • Strategic Vision
      • Management Team
      • What the BDA means to you
      • History
      • Annual Reviews
  • WHAT WE DO
    • SIGN LANGUAGE
      • BSL in GCSE
      • BSL Act Now! Campaign
      • Legal Status for BSL
      • Our work in Government
      • BSL Facts & Resources
      • Research & Consultations
      • Sign Language Week
      • National BSL Day
    • OUR PROJECTS
      • Community Development
      • Training & Consultancy
      • Deaf Roots & Pride
      • Family Sign in the Home
      • Signs of our times
      • Advocacy Service
      • Heritage
      • Dementia Toolkit
      • Dementia Research
      • England Loneliness Project
    • VIDEO INFORMATION IN BSL
      • COVID-19
      • Family Sign at Home
      • Health & Wellbeing
      • Hate Crime Prevention (Scotland)
      • Derbyshire Crime Project
      • Leicestershire Deaf Forum COVID-19 Project
      • Personal Independence Payment (PIP)
      • Access to Justice
  • NEWS & EVENTS
    • NEWS
      • COVID-19
      • All News
      • England
      • Northern Ireland
      • Scotland
      • Wales
    • EVENTS
      • BSL Conference 2025
      • National BSL Day
      • All Events
      • England
      • Northern Ireland
      • Scotland
      • Wales
    • OTHER
      • British Deaf News
      • World Federation of the Deaf
      • European Union of the Deaf
      • SHARE: The Deaf Visual Archive
      • Sign Language Week
      • Deaf Awareness Week
  • GET INVOLVED
    • SUPPORT US
      • Remember A Charity Week 2022
      • Make a difference
      • Ways to Donate
      • Fundraise for the BDA
      • Fundraising Opportunities
      • Sending Sponsorship Money
      • In-Memoriam Donations
      • Gifts in Wills
      • BDA Shop
      • Our Supporters
    • JOIN US
      • Current Job Opportunities
      • Become a Member
    • MORE FROM US
      • Newsletter
  • CONTACT
    • GET IN TOUCH
      • Contact Form
      • 07795 410 724 (SMS)
      • Oovoo/Skype
    • OUR OFFICES
      • England – London
      • England – Derby
      • Northern Ireland – Belfast
      • Scotland – Glasgow
      • Wales – Cardiff
    • SOCIAL MEDIA
      • Twitter
      • Facebook
      • Facebook – British Deaf News
      • Instagram
      • Linkedin
      • YouTube
  • SHOP
  • |
  • MEMBERSHIP
  •  |
  • DONATE

News

29th March 2018

BDA response to Independent article – 12/03/2018

Text transcript of BSL video:

The Independent newspaper recently published an article about Deaf education and the debate of whether Deaf children should learn to sign or to speak – this issue has come to light because of the recent film ‘The Silent Child’. Have a look.

We are writing to express our dismay at a comment article published on The Independent website on 12 March, headlined “I'm glad The Silent Child is changing the narrative around Deaf children – but it's important to remember that sign language is not the only option”. (See an article online via The Independent - tap here)

The author of the piece argues that “Auditory verbal therapy is the key to a deaf child’s success” and questions how any parent would decide not to take that approach.

I would like to make it clear that we do not advocate that deaf children should not learn to talk – we have always encouraged the bilingual approach.

The timing of the publication was unfortunate, coming soon after Sign Language Week in the UK, given that it also implied that sign language users control the narrative or face less discrimination than deaf people who do not sign.

The profound and lasting effects of the poor language access for deaf BSL-users are well documented, and have been highlighted specifically by the United Nations committee on the Convention for the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. Prejudices were also movingly highlighted within the film ‘The Silent Child’ itself; many people are often quick to lower their expectations or aspirations for children who cannot communicate orally.

Deaf sign language users have had innumerable great achievements without needing to use spoken English. Many successful Deaf Sign Language users who are now Professors, Doctors, Lecturers, Teachers, Chief Executives, Directors and Business Entrepreneurs, demonstrate that high aspirations can be achieved by acquiring knowledge and skills through sign language.

Auditory Verbal UK, which will only work with children who are “optimally aided” i.e. who use hearing using aids, cochlear implants or Bone Anchored Hearing Aids (BAHA). It is important for people to realise that AVT is not an option for profoundly Deaf children without technology.

The truth is, any monolingual argument can be damaging. Lack of early language acquisition has profound consequences for children’s development; access and informed choice are imperative. For many parents the opposite is the case when their children are diagnosed as being deaf: the first and only advice they receive is to go for a Cochlear Implant. Never is there the option of bilingualism of both sign language and speech offered.

Surely the best option is that all deaf children can access both BSL and written English and that both languages are respected equally across all fields. That way, parents can make informed choices, and all – not some – of our deaf children can be allowed to thrive.


See an article via The Independent website - tap here.

Or see an article in screenshot image - tap here.


 

Auditory Verbal UK British Sign Language BSL Independent newspaper
Previous Story‘The Silent Child’ wins Oscar
Next StoryCalls to restore the Access to Elected Office Fund

Related Articles

  • WhereistheTerp-Campaign-Update
    #WhereIsTheInterpreter Campaign - Judicial Review
    View Details
  • PSNI-Question-Time-Featured
    PSNI Question Time on Facebook Live
    View Details

SEARCH ALL NEWS

NEWS CATEGORIES

All News
England
Northern Ireland
Scotland
Wales

RECENT NEWS

  • Calling-Deaf-Football-Fans-WEB-Feat
    Press Release: Calling All Deaf Football Fans
  • BSL-Poet-Laur-web-feat
    British Deaf Association reveals the UK’s 2025 British Sign Language Poet Laureate
  • MI Final Reckoning
    Mission: Impossible – Daily Captioned Screenings
  • Classroom-web-feat
    At long last, the BSL GCSE moves closer
  • Houses-of-Parliment
    British Sign Language comes to Parliament

BDA Head Office

We welcome your feedback and comments. Please feel free to get in touch:

Email: bda@bda.org.uk

USEFUL LINKS

Accessibility
Privacy Policy
Complaints Procedure
My Donations
British Deaf News

Registered charity - England and Wales (1031687) and Scotland (SC042409) Company No: 2881497 (England and Wales) - Copyright British Deaf Association 2024